Top ten reasons humans create better indexes than computers
Top Ten - Writing
Top Ten - Design
Top Ten - Production
Top Ten - QC
Top Ten - Indexing
Top Ten - Project Management
Publications trap valuable information when corners are
cut on the back-of-the-book index, according to Jane Rea, EEI's
manager of editorial services. If the publisher settles for a
quick computer-generated index, readers can't always find what
they're looking for. Consider these reasons a human should be
involved in crafting an index that will unlock your next book:
Top Ten - Design
Top Ten - Production
Top Ten - QC
Top Ten - Indexing
Top Ten - Project Management
- Computers create lists of words or phrases and where they appear. Only a human can group related words and phrases under the broad topics we use to seek information.
- It also takes a human to link similar topics with cross-references ("see" and "see also").
- There are lots of words with more than one meaning, even "book" - reading material with covers, or what happens to a suspect down at the station house? Only a human can decide.
- Only a human can judge what topics are important enough to include in the index.
- Not everyone will look for the exact same words that the author used. A human indexer will help by "double posting" (repeating the same information under a synonym).
- Computers are great at carrying out instructions for sorting and formatting. But they need humans to give them instructions.
- There's more than one way to alphabetize an index. A human must decide which method to use.
- Computers don't care if an index includes a string of "undifferentiated references" (six, seven, eight or more pages for a topic). A human will sort that string into sub-topics so readers can find what they are looking for.
- Should the preface, footnotes, charts, and appendices be referenced in the index? A human must judge whether they contain substantive information.
- Sometimes space for an index is limited, and it's tough to get a computer to edit its work to meet that constraint.
Now it's your turn to ask EEI's indexing experts a question. For a bit of free advice, send a brief e-mail to info@eeicom.com.
Client Locations:
Huntsville, AL •
Phoenix, AZ •
Scottsdale, AZ •
Los Angeles, CA •
Sacramento, CA •
San Diego, CA •
San Francisco, CA •
San Jose, CA •
Boulder, CO •
Colorado Springs, CO •
Denver, CO •
Hartford, CT •
Stanford, CT •
Washington, DC •
Wilmington, DE •
Boca Raton, FL •
Jacksonville, FL •
Miami, FL •
Orlando, FL •
Tampa, FL •
Atlanta, GA •
Honolulu, HI •
Boise, ID •
Chicago, IL •
Springfield, IL •
Indianapolis, IN •
Louisville, KY •
New Orleans, LA •
Boston, MA •
Cambridge, MA •
Annapolis, MD •
Baltimore, MD •
Bethesda, MD •
Bowie, MD •
Fredrick, MD •
Germantown, MD •
Hunt Valley, MD •
Rockville, MD •
Silver Spring, MD •
Towson, MD •
Ann Arbor, MI •
Detroit, MI •
Minneapolis, MN •
Charlotte, NC •
Newark, NJ •
Princeton, NJ •
Trenton, NJ •
Albuquerque, NM •
Las Vegas, NV •
Albany, NY •
Buffalo, NY •
New York City, NY •
Rochester, NY •
Syracuse, NY •
Cincinnati, OH •
Cleveland, OH •
Columbus, OH •
Philadelphia, PA •
Pittsburgh, PA •
York, PA •
Rapid City, SD •
Memphis, TN •
Nashville, TN •
Austin, TX •
Dallas, TX •
Fort Worth, TX •
Houston, TX •
San Antonio, TX •
Alexandria, VA •
Arlington, VA •
Dulles, VA •
Fairfax, VA •
Herndon, VA •
Reston, VA •
Richmond, VA •
Virginia Beach, VA •
Seattle, WA •
Milwaukee, WI
